Campbells Chunky - thick and starchy right out of the can, but at full heat turns into nearly perfect consistency. Lots of clams and a fair amount of potato. Still somewhat bland, needs to be seasoned - celery salt, pepper makes a big difference. Not bad, though. 7/10
New England Country Soup - Outstanding. Perfect consistency. Loads of clams and potatoes. Rich broth made with real cream and butter, and it tastes it. Interesting flavor note from the hint of dill that they use, even though I usually dislike dill this was very nice. Top contender. In a pouch. New England Country Foods LLC, Manchester Village VT 05254 www.NewEnglandCountrySoup.net 9+/10
Valu Time (Topco "generic") - Decent flavor, lots of potatos, adequate amount of clams. Unnaturally white. Thick, starchy, gluey. It jiggles in the spoon. Token amounts of cream and butter in the broth, mostly modified food starch. 5/10
Progresso - Good consistency, not overthickened. Big hearty chunks of potatoes, lots of clams (small pieces.) Very deep flavor with shellfishy notes thanks to addition of lobster powder, shrimp, crab powder, and fish powder. DATEM (Diacetyl Tartaric (Acid) Ester of Monoglyceride) added (emulsifyer) prob because the chowder is gluten-free. A more natural color, not weirdly white. A bit underseasoned, was better after adding some black pepper. I heated it up in the microwave; interestingly enough, it started out very very thick but within a few minutes (as it cooled) it got thinner 8/10
Big Y Chunky - Lots of potatoes, adequate amount of clams. Like Valu Time, unnaturally white. Freakishly thick, so thick and starchy a spoon could stand in it unassisted. Odd non-clam aftertaste was vaguely brackish. Would not ever buy this one again. 2/10